Simulated Law Class with Professor Val Ricks

by Chrissy Biello

Every spring, the Sam Houston Center for Law, Engagement, and Politics invites South Texas College of Law Professor Val Ricks to teach a Mock Law Class. Professor Ricks is a renowned legal mind and a national expert in contracts, among other areas of law.

Approximately thirty students attended this year’s session; any student at Sam Houston State University was able to register for the event. Before the class, participants were expected to prepare with case materials that Professor Ricks provided.

The mock case, Joseph Vian v. Mariah Carey (1993), focused on the legal concept of consideration and whether a valid contract existed between Mr. Vian and Ms. Carey. Professor Ricks opened the session by providing a working definition of law, saying that it revolves around the precise words used in legal documents.

He then employed an analogy comparing law to chess. Finding a self-identified chess player in the audience, Professor Ricks guided students to understand the parallel between chess rules and legal principles. Both systems operate within defined parameters; they require much thinking and a thorough understanding of established rules.

When moving on to the case discussion, Professor Ricks first told the class the facts of the case, then activated his random number generator to begin his use of the Socratic Method. From this, selected students were asked numerous questions about the case; Professor Ricks insisted they cite directly from the text, reinforcing his earlier point that the law is “all about the words.”

Once the class reached a general consensus on the case interpretation, Professor Ricks opened the floor for questions. Pre-Law Society President, Olivia Discon, asked what undergraduate students could do to prepare for law school. After thoughtful consideration, Professor Ricks began to speak on his own experience. He explained that studying scholastic philosophy during his undergraduate years was truly helpful; the language structure closely resembled legal texts, easing his transition into law school. 

By the end of the session, students had not only sharpened their legal reasoning skills but also gained a clearer picture of what to expect in law school. Professor Ricks once again allowed students to sit in the shoes of a law student for an hour.  By challenging students to truly understand the case and come out of their shells, he provided a better understanding of the power of precise language in the study of law.

Appeals on Wheels: 9th Court of Appeals Version

by Michelle Moya

As we count down the days until our 10th annual Court of Appeals visit at SHSU, we had the opportunity to hear the 9th Court of Appeals in Conroe! Typically based in Beaumont, the court traveled to hear oral arguments for two appeal cases. Given the distinct jurisdictions and caseloads of the 9th and 10th Courts of Appeals, Pre-Law President Olivia, newly elected Pre-Law Secretary Laila, and I took it upon ourselves to hear different perspectives in the courts!

As we approached the James Keeshan Courthouse, we noticed a car license plate in the parking lot, with a message that might it somewhat unsurprising that its owner was needing to park in court.

But with time running short, we moved with dispatch to the courtroom, noting that the attorneys were set up and readying themselves for court.

Similar to our own 10th Court of Appeals, there was a three-judge panel presiding: Chief Justice Scott Golemon, Justice Leanne Johnson, and Justice Jay Wright for the first case. The first case was Siluria LLC v. Lummus Technology, LLC, and it centered around a complex contract-construction issue. Attorney Rusty Sewell delivered a 15-minute oral argument on behalf of Siluria, followed by Attorney Thomas Kruse’s argument for Lummus. The crux of the argument revolved around the interpretation of a phrase in the party’s Escrow Agreement: “begun removing the demonstration unit.” What’s interesting is that both parties agreed on the facts, but they had differing interpretations of the agreement, which they both claimed was clear-cut. It was interesting to see how every word truly does count in law–and also seeing what a “hot panel” looks like.

After a brief recess, the second case began: City of Houston v. Festival Props., Inc. To our surprise, the appellant was the City of Houston, represented by attorney Donald Hightower, while the appellee was Festival Properties, Inc., represented by Attorney Marie D. Harlan. It centered around a claim of inverse condemnation against the City of Houston, alleging a loss of access to property. Watching the proceedings, it was interesting seeing the pointed questions, pushing the attorneys to think and respond thoughtfully. Despite the attorneys’ well-reasoned responses, the justices’ questions underscored the complexity of the issues at hand.

For those of us aspiring to enter the legal profession, this experience reinforced the importance of thinking critically under pressure. It was interesting to see firsthand the challenges of presenting complex arguments, thinking on your feet, and navigating the intricacies of the law.

The hearings were not only interesting for their content, but also as networking opportunity. We met Ms. Deborah Concepcion, who is a Managing Attorney at Lone Star Legal Aid, and she told us a bit about her career, her passion for helping others, and some of the ins and outs of court room appearances. We also met Zachary Dickens, who was in the Pre-Law Society as an undergraduate before going to law school, and he now works at Polk County as a prosecutor.

As we get closer to the 10th Court of Appeals visit, I am even more eagerly anticipating their upcoming visit. I’m excited to see new people, learn more about life in law, and see the cases that the 10th Court of Appeals will bring to SHSU.

Some Are Born Great, Some Just See it on Stage

by Olivia Discon

Somehow, within the span of one year, an organization devoted to “law, engagement, and politics” has managed to see 10 plays in a 12-month period. the most recent of these was this past Saturday, when we saw Twelfth Night by William Shakespeare, performed by SHSU’s Department of Theatre and Musical Theatre.

To briefly summarize, the play begins with a shipwreck that separates twins, Viola and Sebastian. Believing her brother to be lost at sea, Viola disguises herself as a man named Cesario and enters the service of Duke Orsino. Orsino, deeply in love with Lady Olivia, sends Cesario (Viola) to woo Olivia on his behalf. However, Olivia falls for Cesario, unaware of Viola’s true identity, while Viola herself harbors feelings for Orsino. In other words, a true kerfuffle!

With any good Shakespeare play, there is a fantastic subplot. Olivia’s steward, Malvolio, becomes the target of a prank by Maria, Sir Toby Belch, Sir Andrew Aguecheek, and Fabian. They trick him into believing Olivia loves him by forging a letter, along with some absurd instructions—wear yellow stockings, cross-gartered, and smile constantly at Olivia, who only welcomes melancholy. Malvolio’s monologue was by far my favorite moment in the play, as the humor of the prank is unfolding alongside a quite passionate and unwitting Malvolio.

Ultimately, as with all Shakespeare’s comedies, the play ends with multiple reunions and resolutions. Viola’s true identity is revealed, allowing her to reunite with her lost twin, Sebastian. Olivia, who had fallen for Cesario (Viola in disguise), is surprised but happy to find herself married to Sebastian instead. Orsino, realizing Viola’s love for him, shifts his affections and proposes to her. Meanwhile, the prank on Malvolio is exposed, but he exits vowing revenge rather than joining in the happy ending.

SHSU’s approach to the play, in terms of design, was quite interesting to me. With a 1920’s Art Deco style, one could imagine the themes of living in excess, false appearances and social ambition. In all, our group thought everything was well executed, entertaining, and all the more thought provoking. If this crowd was any judge of the performance, then the SHSU Theatre Department delivered a hit!